Howard J. C. Some Sculpture-Anthropology Relations: Reading the agency of Franz Boas and Lev Sternberg

JEREMY C. HOWARD — PhD, Senior Lecturer, School of Art History, University of St Andrews (St Andrews, Scotland, UK)
E-mail: jch2@st-andrews.ac.uk

 

Download  |  Go to Issue #4. 2020

 

ABSTRACT. This article deliberates arguments for sculpture being considered ‘the most anthropological of the arts’. After introducing British contentions for the anthropological aspect of sculpture (Barlow, Gell, Ades and Bunn), it then applies, not without a hint of irony, the concept to sculpture specifically made for anthropological and ethnographic museums, using examples instigated by Franz Boas and Lev Sternberg (for the United States National Museum in the 1890s and the Kunstkamera in the 1910s). Hence mannequins and copies of Kwakiutl and pre-Hispanic Andean ritual figures (living and carved) are, respectively, explored. Correlations with associated acquisitions are made, e.g. Nivkh and Kadiwéu wood carvings, these involving their contemporary analysis by Voldemārs Matvejs and Alberto Vojtěch Frič. Particular attention is paid to Sternberg’s commission of concrete copies of the San Agustín megaliths from Karl Theodor Stoepel. The subsequent placement of these in the Kunstkamera courtyard is probed in terms of potential altered meanings, identity and agency. Thereafter the enquiry moves to examination of the ‘sculpted anthropologist’, again using Boas and Sternberg as case studies. Ultimately, through the combination of these two distinct and direct anthropological sides of sculpture, a restricted case is made for the plastic art’s anthropological identity.

 

KEYWORDS: sculpture, anthropology, Boas, Sternberg, Kunstkamera

 

УДК 069:39
DOI 10.31250/2618-8619-2020-4(10)-140-156

 

REFERENCES

  • Ades D. Henry Moore and World Sculpture. Henry Moore // Sculptural Process and Public Identity. London, Tate Research Publication, 2015 URL: https://www.tate.org.uk/art/research-publications/henry-moore/dawn-ades-henry-moore-and- world-sculpture-r1151458 (accessed 23.11.2020).
  • Bone J. [J.B.]. The London Group looks back // The Manchester Guardian. 2 May 1928 P. 12
  • Botera Clara Isabel. Construction of the pre-Hispanic past of Colombia: Collections, Museums and Early Archaeology 1823–1941 // Oxford: DPhil. Thesis, 2001
  • Bunn S. The Importance of Materials // Journal of Museum Ethnography. 1999 (11) P. 15–28.
  • Consummatum Est // The Times. 22 October 1937 P. 14
  • Epstein J. Let there be sculpture. London, 1940
  • Frič A. V. Onoenrgodi-Gott und Idole der Kad’uevo in Matto Grosso // International Congress of Americanists: Proceedings of the XVIII. Session, London, 1912 London, 1913 P. 397–407.
  • Gell A. Art and Agency: An Anthropological Theory. Oxford, 1998
  • Glass A. Frozen Poses: Hamat’sa Dioramas, Recursive Representation, and the Making of a Kwakwaka’wakw Icon // Christopher Morton, Christopher, Edwards Elizabeth (eds.). Photography, Anthropology and History: Expanding the Frame. London and New York, 2009 P. 89–117.
  • Hinsley C. M., Holm B. A Cannibal in the National Museum: The Early Career of Franz Boas in America // American Anthropologist. 1976 Vol. 78 (2). P. 306–316.
  • Howard J., Bužinska I., Strother Z. S. Vladimir Markov and Russian Primitivism: A Charter for the Avant-Garde. Farnham, 2015
  • Kan S. Lev Sternberg. Anthropologist, Russian Socialist, Jewish Activist. Lincoln and London, 2009
  • Křížová M. “The History of Human Stupidity”: Vojtěch Frič and his Program of a Comparative Study of Religions // Thenologia Actualis. 2018 Vol. 18 (1). P. 42–67.
  • N. An Epstein Riddle // The Manchester Guardian. 22 October 1937 P. 12
  • New Epsteins: Portraits in Bronze Now on Exhibition in London // The Illustrated London News, 23 October 1937 P. 723
  • Our Correspondent. New Work by Epstein // The Yorkshire Post. 23 October 1937 P. 10
  • Our Own Correspondent. New work by Jacob Epstein // The Nottingham Journal. 22 October 1937 P. 9
  • Sternberg L. The Social Organization of the Gilyak. Seattle, 1999
  • Sternberg L. The Turano-Ganowanian System and the Nations of North-East Asia // International Congress of Americanists: Proceedings of the XVIII. Session, London, 1912 London, 1913 P. 319–333.
  • Stoepel K. Th. Archaelogical Discoveries in Ecuador and Southern Colombia during 1911; and the Ancient Stone Monuments of San Agustin // International Congress of Americanists: Proceedings of the XVIII. Session, London, 1912 London, 1913 P. 251–258.
  • Warkentin J. Creating Memory: A Guide to Outdoor Public Sculpture in Toronto. Toronto, 2010
  • Аборигены Америки: предметы и представления. СПб., 2005 (Сборник МАЭ. Т. V).
  • Дмитренко Л. М., Кондакова О. В. Материалы рукописного архива музея им. Напрстека (Прага, Чехия) как источник изучения и атрибуции коллекций Альберта Войтеха Фрича в собрании МАЭ // Кунсткамера. 2019 № 3 (5). С. 85–96.
  • Кинжалов Р. И. Статуи сан-Аугустина (из американских коллекций МАЭ) // Музей, традиции, этничность ХХ–ХХІ вв. СПб.; Кишинев, 2002 C. 146–147.
  • Корсун C. A. Л. Я. Штернберг как американист // Лев Штернберг — гражданин, ученый, педагог. К 150-летию со дня рождения / под ред. E. A. Резвана. СПб., 2012 С. 65-82.
  • Матвеева П. А. «Все человечество едино»: В. В. Радлов и МАЭ. СПб., 2014
  • Штернберг Л. Я. Семья и род у народов Северо-Восточной Азии. Л., 1933